PRINT  |   SHARE:        rss feed |  

Disturbing Trend: Police on Dog Violence

Lisa Shenkle

Cisco, Chloe, Kincaid, Sassy, Ziggy, Chase and Payton – this is a story about family dogs and the people who love them. This is also a story about the law enforcement officers who killed them.

On April 14, 2012, a domestic disturbance call went out to the Austin, Texas police department.  Police responding to the call saw Michael Paxton come from his backyard into the driveway, where he was immediately told to stop while a gun was drawn on him and he was held at gunpoint.  Within moments, Cisco, an Australian Cattle Dog, came around the corner from the backyard to be with his owner.  Cisco responded, as most dogs will when someone is on their property, and barked at the officer – who, without hesitation – shot Cisco dead, in front of his owner.

That domestic disturbance call? Police were at the wrong address.  They not only responded to the incorrect address, they held an innocent man at gunpoint and killed his pet.

This is not the first time law enforcement has shown up at the wrong doorstep and left dead dogs in the wake of their mistake.  In late July 2008, a Maryland SWAT team invaded the home of the then Mayor of Berwyn Heights, Cheye Calvo in what looked like a scene out of a Hollywood blockbuster.  They threw his mother-in-law (who was making spaghetti sauce at the time) on the floor, cuffed them both and shot Calvo’s two black Labradors.  When SWAT team members entered the home by crashing through the door, one sleeping dog got up to see what was going on and was shot dead. The other dog was trying to run away and was shot three times.  Blood was everywhere, Calvo was distraught and the answer to their grief amid intimidating interrogation was to have an officer cover up their dead bodies with dog beds until animal control could come to get them.

Just this week, in Adams County Colorado, Ziggy, a 35-pound blue heeler/border collie mix was gunned down by local law enforcement when they mistakenly forced entry into a workshop business while responding to an alarm. Ziggy ran past the police, out the front door; while headed back to his owner, Jeff Fischer, Ziggy was shot on the way back inside. Fischer alleges that Ziggy was at least 15 feet away from the officer when shot and displayed no aggression during the episode. This is the second such incident of its kind in Adams County and citizens are outraged. Police Officer Robert Price has been charged by the Adams County District Attorney with aggravated cruelty to animals in the first incident which killed a dog named Chloe.  A video of the event, taken by a neighbor and posted online, helped to secure the charges.

On New Year’s Day, according to reports, Baltimore City police chased a suspect through a neighborhood.  The suspect ran down an alleyway, jumped a fence into a yard and down the outside basement steps of a third party home in an effort to evade police.  The officer drew the gun on the suspect, who was at the bottom of the stairs.  Kincaid, in his own yard, came off the front porch to investigate the commotion, as he was doing so, he barked.  Just as Edward Augustine, resident of the home, went to reach for Kincaid’s harness, the officer – who had yelled for Augustine to restrain the dog—reportedly fired six shots, three of which hit Kincaid, killing him.  Witnesses say the officer put Augustine in danger as well, nearly missing him with the shots.  The officer had not yet detained, cuffed or searched the detainee before any of this happened. 

Baltimore City’s Northeast District police will not comment on the shooting.  Owner of Kincaid, Stacy Fields, tells FUROCIOUS “The officer told Ed to get Kincaid and as he [Augustine] reached to grab his harness, the officer turned from the suspect and fired 6 shots. He missed Kincaid 3 times and hit him 3 times.”

As someone raised in a law enforcement family, the members of which were, and are, ‘expert’ level marksmen, I can tell you there is more than one thing wrong with a statement that a police officer, who is required to carry a gun every day, fires six shots and connects with only three at close range – especially if he contends the animal was charging him. But, I digress.  Stacy and her family have yet to receive an apology.  She awaits the scheduling of a meeting that Major Richard Worley has suggested and she intends to file a civil suit. She has received no communication from anyone officially from city government - including one from the Mayor’s Anti-Animal Abuse Commission, which, according to Stacy, parroted the statement on the police department’s Facebook page.  She contends that Kincaid had no history of violence.  A peaceful vigil last Saturday morning outside the Northeast District headquarters attracted about 40 individuals.

Make no mistake. FUROCIOUS understands, more than most from personal experience, the sacrifices that families in law enforcement, and officers on duty, make every day.  We understand that police are not infallible and that they also make mistakes.  We agree that it is an officer’s right to protect themselves, and acknowledge it is their duty to the community to do so as well.  FUROCIOUS is often upset by news reports of suspects who do not obey officer commands to stand down, often which result in a suspect being shot and, sometimes, killed.  Members of our law enforcement community must expect cooperation in the act of apprehending someone, criminal or not, for those who do not comply, are perceived as hostile and dangerous.

But police officers are also members of our communities.  They are trained professionals from whom we seek protection, advice and counsel.  We hope to have conversations with them as they drive and walk our streets, we hope they will become familiar with our neighborhoods and businesses so they might notice when something is out of place or appears suspicious.  In effect, this is a relationship. 

We do not expect to have sheriffs’ deputies or police officers entering our property unlawfully, or with a warrant, and shooting our dogs dead.  Certainly, if a dog is in the act of attacking (ready to lunge, teeth and gums exposed, biting), we understand a shot to injure, or kill, may be an appropriate response. However, if a dog owner is attending to the pet, attempting to move the dog out of an escalating situation, we expect to have everyone come out of that situation alive – including the dog. 

Questions need to be asked and an honest dialogue needs to begin about why deadly force is being used preemptively.  Is this a lack of an appropriate assessment of situational awareness?  Are officers operating under more stress and therefore not able to determine a ‘real’ vs. ‘perceived’ threat? Or are some officers just, quite honestly, afraid of dogs, which could stem from a childhood incident or family influences when it comes to domestic animals?

This is not to relieve dog parents of their responsibilities either.  However, in the aforementioned cases, I am unsure as to what those dog owners could have done differently which would have resulted in a better ending.

FUROCIOUS hopes that in the case of the Baltimore shooting, the Mayor’s Anti-Animal Abuse Advisory Commission will use this as an opportunity to create a public, practical, meaningful, productive discussion with the Baltimore City Police. We need to learn how we can avoid future incidents of this kind and if that, in fact, translates into more police training and community awareness. Baltimoreans already know that when called to the scene of a ‘vicious dog’ report in Baltimore last spring, Officer Dan Waskiewicz and his astute assessment of a pitbull at the scene, had a much better ending than all of these other stories.  The pitbull, having been chased and pummeled with bottles by neighborhood kids approached Officer Waskiewicz with his tail between his legs. He determined the dog was not a threat - which, days later, ultimately resulted in the officer adopting the dog he now calls “Bo.” For his appropriate response, Officer Waskiewicz was honored by the Baltimore Humane Society.

In April of 2012, the law firm Joseph, Greenwald & Laake (JGL) announced in a press release that “a Maryland jury returned a $620,000 verdict against two Frederick County Sheriff’s Deputies for violating the constitutional rights of a Frederick County family” which resulted in the seriously wounding their chocolate Labrador, who will now need lifelong medical care and treatment.  The dog, a the time of the shooting incident, was never more than three feet near the deputies and had ceased barking prior to when the deputy pulled the trigger. According to this release (http://news.yahoo.com/620-000-verdict-frederick-county-maryland-police-dog-070850853.html) the incident was caught on video.

Carey J. Hansel of Joseph, Greenwald & Laake, one of two attorneys representing the victims in this case said “The verdict makes it clear that Maryland citizens will not tolerate the killing and maiming of innocent family pets by those in positions of power. The jury valiantly defended our constitutional rights to be secure from this violence on our property and to be safe in our own homes. This is a victory for the constitution and for all Maryland citizens.”

So, message to Baltimore – the citizens do not have to accept this behavior from law enforcement.  The maiming and killing of our pets does not serve to build bridges, but rather disintegrate them.  These are our neighborhoods, these are members of our family, let’s work together.

To keep up on the progress on Kincaid, you can “like” his Facebook page to follow the story more closely at https://www.facebook.com/pages/Kincaid-Killed-by-Baltimore-City-Police/129570580537016.

Posted by .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) on 01/16/13 at 05:22 PM

Let us know what you think…

name:       email address:        Remember me

These incidents of violence have to be stopped, the local authorities should come up with laws to protect these helpless animals. However, if you have a pet dog then you should take care of its health, make sure you feed him nutritious food and you should also take it for regular walking on the street. If you do not have time for such activities then you have to take help of dog walking services NYC.

Posted by labpro on 02/19/15 at 06:29 AM

Such incidents have to be stopped immediately, the police should not shoot these animals without any reason. The pet owners need to consult with the local authorities to change the laws. However, now most pet related items are available online, you can find fun costumes for your dog or cat online. Not just that but at places like http://swalefandson.com/geneticroostersaddlepatches.aspx you can find decorative rooster feathers as well.

Posted by modhu on 01/20/15 at 08:04 AM

There should be a strict law to prevent such incidents in future. The dog owners must appeal to the government to keep their dogs safe. However, now there are good facilities available for taking care of health problems of their pet, in fact some of the facilities also offer breeding programs. For horse owners Pollyrich Farms Inc. is the best place for taking their horses for breeding, this facility is available online at http://pollyrichfarms.com.

Posted by morrison on 01/12/15 at 08:40 AM

The authorities have to be informed about the incidents and they should take the right steps to prevent such incidents. However, the pet owners should too consider keeping their dogs away from the cops. Most pet owners stress a lot about their pet’s health issues, they should approach a vet facility like Longenbaugh Veterinary Hospital which is the most reputed animal clinic Copperfield.

Posted by morrison on 01/08/15 at 05:19 AM

Such incidents are indeed very pathetic for pet owners and animal lovers. They need to bring these incidents to the notice of the authorities to put a stop to this. However, festival time is here and it is a time to have fun, if you love animals then you could take your kids to a popular Easter petting zoo Dallas area where they would learn to be kind to these animals.

Posted by dana on 01/02/15 at 07:08 AM

Such incidents should be stopped, they should not shoot the dogs without any reason. However, the dog owners need to keep their dogs secure too, especially when they are leaving home for few days. It would be better if they hire a reputed dog shelter like Paw Print Inn, you can find more about them at http://www.pawprintinn.com/dog_accommodations.html.

Posted by patinson on 12/22/14 at 05:15 AM

Buy premium dog run panels in 5cm and 8cm bar panels here, we carry large stocks and offer a fast and efficient delivery on all your dog kennel requirements. contact us

Posted by Allen on 11/28/14 at 06:01 AM

Buy cheap dog food online - Buy dog food, cat food, small animal food you normally obtain from your vet. Buy prescription vet ranges today online from Vets Food World.

Posted by Allen on 11/28/14 at 06:00 AM

It`s great to hear that the Mayor’s Anti-Animal Abuse Advisory Commission came with a couple of solutions that would stop such cases happen. It`s hard to accept that your pet was shot dead by a police officer that considered him as a threat, in this case the best thing to do is to contact Foran & Foran lawyers as their level of expertise is great and they will help anyone.

Posted by chadmonkens on 11/26/14 at 06:17 PM

“When you’ve got youngsters you would like back-up and also you get acquainted with the neighbours.” chanel
The particular selling is not going to create levy sales as a consequence of exemptions relevant to entice dangerous buyers and complicated business constructions set up to take advantage of most of these procedures. Thus the state of hawaii loses about NIS 500m. シャネル公式サイト
(Fox news) シャネル ルースパウダー
Contact Karina Ioffee with . Comply with your ex with .  chanel 化粧品
I in ‘s.net Friday in which Hoar System Managing possesses picked out general contractors with the 2 leftover projects linked to the under construction at Portable Aeroplex at Brookley. シャネル チーク 人気
There we were a few of the very first to work with Samsung monte Carlo study to check this tactic throughout a large number of diverse marketplace circumstances. All of us discovered that you possess an 50 to 90 % potential for not necessarily not having enough money after 3 decades. シャネル ポーチ
Charlotte now, N.Do. (AP) — Phil Mickelson ended up being entertaining towards the end Thurs and just one chance at the rear of Angel Cabrera within the first around with the Wells Fargo Tournament.
シャネル コピー

Posted by シャネル コピー on 05/17/14 at 01:49 PM

I would go right at one of the specialists from [url=http://www.whmlaw.com]http://www.whmlaw.com[/url] website in case a police officer would harm my pet and I am sure he will do everything possible to help me. Also I installed home surveillance cameras in all the rooms from my house and I would have strong evidence in case something like this would happen.

Posted by tonibrinton on 05/05/14 at 05:45 AM

The violence is really something. We have got to do something to make ourselves a little bit better. - BrandStar Entertainment

Posted by jenny_foxie on 04/07/14 at 09:55 PM

it’s a great post and ai like your mind in this post thank’s for yoru information
do might also like obat gondok in order to obat alami kanker otak yang aman

Posted by hilmansuhilman on 03/18/14 at 12:03 AM

keep up with style
Style Pinterest
Style Twitter
Style Facebook

Subscribe to this blog

You can follow Lisa Shenkle's blog by subscribing to the RSS feed here.

If you would like to have the latest blog posts delivered to your inbox enter your email address below: